By Art Gharibian | Founder and Managing Attorney, Gharibian Law, APC
Throughout my career representing victims of elder abuse and neglect, I have witnessed how nursing homes and assisted living facilities use legal agreements to limit accountability when residents suffer preventable injuries or death. One of the most significant challenges in these cases is the widespread use of arbitration agreements.
For families, the decision to place a loved one in a nursing home is often emotional and overwhelming. They trust these facilities to provide proper care, supervision, and protection. What many families do not realize is that among the numerous documents presented during admission may be an arbitration agreement that significantly affects their legal rights.
As an attorney whose practice focuses on elder abuse, neglect, and wrongful death, challenging these agreements is an important part of my work. Over the past several years, I have authored and co-authored three articles published in Advocate Magazine examining the legal framework governing nursing home arbitration agreements and significant developments in California appellate law.
Understanding the Problem: Nursing Home Arbitration Agreements
In September 2023, I authored “Nursing Home Arbitration Agreements in California – Understanding the Basics” examining contract formation, agency authority, unconscionability, statutory protections, and agreements signed by family members.
Families are frequently asked to sign extensive admission paperwork while dealing with a loved one’s declining health, hospitalization, or urgent need for placement. An arbitration agreement may be presented alongside routine healthcare documents, even though it addresses how future legal disputes will be resolved.
I believe families should never feel pressured to surrender their right to pursue justice in court simply because their loved one needs nursing home care. Whether the signer had authority and whether the agreement complied with California law are especially important when residents have cognitive impairments.
A Significant Victory for Residents’ Rights: The California Supreme Court Weighs In
In September 2024, I co-authored an article with attorney Amber Tham examining Harrod v. Country Oaks Partners, LLC (2024) 15 Cal.5th 939. The California Supreme Court addressed whether an agent authorized to make healthcare decisions could also execute a separate, optional arbitration agreement on a resident’s behalf. The court concluded that signing such an agreement was not a healthcare decision within that authority.
The authority to make medical decisions does not automatically include the authority to determine how someone’s future legal claims will be resolved. In my view, the decision reinforced an essential principle: protecting someone’s health and welfare should not be confused with surrendering their legal rights.
Another Turning Point: The Limits of Arbitration in Elder-Abuse Litigation
In September 2026, Amber Tham and I co-authored “A Turning Point for Elder-Abuse Cases” discussing Holland v. Silverscreen Healthcare and the evolving legal limits of arbitration in elder-abuse litigation.
Nursing home defendants frequently seek to move disputes away from court by relying on arbitration provisions executed during admission. Those disputes may involve preventable falls, pressure injuries, malnutrition, dehydration, and failures to provide necessary care. The questions are more than procedural technicalities; they can determine whether families can present claims in a public courtroom before a jury.
The evolving case law underscores the need to examine each agreement and its legal boundaries rather than assume that a signature automatically resolves the issue.
Why Transparency and Accountability Matter
My concerns about routine nursing home arbitration agreements are rooted in the broader need for accountability. Public court proceedings can reveal problems extending beyond one resident, including understaffing, inadequate training, failures to implement care plans, and systemic supervision breakdowns.
Arbitration generally takes place in a private forum. Although it may be appropriate in some circumstances, serious concerns arise when residents or families never knowingly or validly agreed to it. Elderly individuals and dependent adults deserve meaningful legal safeguards.
My Commitment to Elder-Abuse Advocacy
As founder and managing attorney of Gharibian Law, APC, I have dedicated my practice to representing families affected by elder abuse, neglect, and wrongful death in nursing homes and assisted living facilities. My work extends beyond pursuing compensation for individual clients. Attorneys in this field must understand developing law, challenge practices that undermine residents’ rights, and contribute to improving long-term care.
From my 2023 examination of arbitration fundamentals to my 2024 analysis of Harrod and my 2026 discussion of Holland, one theme runs through my writing: Nursing home residents and their families deserve meaningful access to justice, and their legal rights should not be taken away through agreements they did not knowingly or validly authorize.
I remain committed to protecting elderly and dependent adults, holding negligent facilities accountable, and helping ensure that vulnerable members of our communities receive the dignity and care they deserve.
At Gharibian Law, we focus on representing victims of elder abuse and nursing home neglect throughout California. If you believe your loved one may have suffered preventable harm, I encourage you to contact our office for a free, confidential consultation.
Art Gharibian
Managing Attorney | Gharibian Law, APC
Glendale, California
(877) 460-1187
www.gharibianlaw.com
This article is intended for general informational purposes only and does not constitute legal advice. Every case depends on its specific facts and circumstances. Reading this article or contacting the firm does not, by itself, establish an attorney-client relationship.


